What’s Really Behind High Grocery Prices?
Grocery store prices have made headlines every day this summer as American families continue to grapple with the financial strain of high food costs. What’s causing these price hikes? While inflation is part of the story, it’s clear that corporate practices, market consolidation and price fixing, and emerging technologies are also at play.
The Scale of the Problem
Since 2020, food prices have surged by a staggering 26 percent, outpacing overall inflation and taking a significant bite out of household budgets. This sharp increase has had dire consequences for many Americans. According to USDA data released last week, the rate of food insecurity has climbed to 13.5 percent in 2023 from 12.8 percent in 2022, meaning about 1 in 8 Americans now faces food insecurity.
Beyond Inflation: Corporate Practices and Profit-Seeking
While inflation has been a significant driver of rising prices across the economy, the grocery sector has seen price increases that go beyond what inflation alone can explain. A 2022 FTC report found that food and beverage retailers took advantage of the pandemic to hike prices and boost profits. Grocery prices are up 21 percent in the last three years while major chains saw revenue spikes up to 36 percent.
In a stark admission under questioning from a Federal Trade Commission attorney last month, a top Kroger executive acknowledged that the company had raised prices for eggs and milk above the rate of inflation, stating in an internal email that “retail inflation has been significantly higher than cost inflation” for these items.
Investors have taken note of this profit-driven approach. Major grocery chain stocks have significantly outperformed the market in recent years. Over the past five years, Walmart's stock has risen 102 percent, Kroger's by 117 percent, and Costco's by a whopping 190 percent. These gains suggest that Wall Street is rewarding grocers for their pricing strategies, potentially at consumers’ expense.
Market Consolidation and Price Fixing Drive Up Costs
The grocery industry has also become increasingly concentrated, with major players seeking to consolidate further. The proposed $25 billion merger between Kroger and Albertsons, which CRFB opposes, exemplifies this trend. If approved, the merger would create a grocery giant controlling about 13 percent of the U.S. market, reducing competition and giving the new entity greater power to drive up prices.
The FTC alleges that a merger between Kroger and Albertsons would drive up prices for millions of American families.
The consolidation trend extends beyond retail. In the meat processing industry, a handful of companies dominate the market. A recent lawsuit against data analytics firm Agri Stats alleges that the company facilitated a price-fixing scheme among major meat processors, which collectively account for over 90 percent of broiler chicken sales, 80 percent of pork sales, and 90 percent of turkey sales in the United States. Given that top food and agribusiness companies have been fined well over $2 billion for price fixing and anti-competitive practices since 2000, this is clearly yet another factor contributing to higher grocery store prices for consumers.
Technology: A Double-Edged Sword
Emerging technologies are also reshaping how grocers set prices. Kroger, for instance, has faced criticism for implementing an AI-powered "dynamic pricing" model in 500 of its stores. While such systems could potentially offer efficiencies, they also raise concerns about privacy and fairness. These digital price tags could enable practices like surge pricing based on factors such as weather or time of day, potentially exacerbating consumers’ financial stress.
External Shocks and Supply Chain Vulnerabilities
Along with corporate practices, external factors and supply chain disruptions have also played a significant role in rising food prices. Climate change has led to more frequent extreme weather events like floods and droughts, affecting crop yields and livestock herd sizes. Russia’s ongoing war in Ukraine has disrupted global grain markets, while outbreaks of bird flu have impacted poultry and egg production. And, of course, the COVID-19 pandemic caused shockwaves that rippled throughout the food supply chain. However, some of the pandemic's impacts were overblown; for instance, a federal investigation found that Tyson Foods and other major meat companies lied about shortages in pursuit of higher profits.
These events have exposed the vulnerabilities of our consolidated, industrialized, and globalized food system. The concentration of production in fewer, larger operations makes the entire system more susceptible to disruptions from disease outbreaks, geopolitical conflicts, or climate events. This lack of resilience underpins supply shortages and increased production costs, further complicating the food price landscape and ultimately forcing consumers to bear an undue burden.
Moreover, it is concerning that food manufacturers and retailers have taken advantage of these shocks to mislead the public and raise prices when Americans were already struggling. Consumers may rightly feel cheated “if the worst of times for ordinary people ends up being the best of times for corporations,” noted University of Massachusetts Amherst economist Isabella Weber. “Some sort of basic social contract is kind of crumpling.”
A congressional investigation found that Tyson Foods and other major meat companies lied about shortages and unnecessarily put plant workers' health at risk during the COVID-19 pandemic.
The Impact on American Households
Regardless of the reasons behind rising food costs, many Americans are feeling the pain. In 2023, U.S. households spent an average of 11.2 percent of their budgets on food. That’s still less than the 14.3 percent of disposable income the average European household spends on food, but combined with other economic factors like high housing and healthcare costs, it can cause serious financial strain. Many American families are forced to make difficult trade-offs between nutritious food and other essential expenses.
The situation is particularly dire for recipients of Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) benefits. A survey found that 97 percent of SNAP recipients say their current benefits are not enough to cover rising costs, and 91 percent believe losing their benefits would lead to food insecurity.
Towards Balanced Solutions
Addressing the issue of rising food prices requires a multifaceted approach that balances consumer welfare, market efficiency, and fiscal responsibility. The following policy measures should be implemented:
Strengthening antitrust enforcement to maintain healthy market competition and blocking large mergers such as the one between Kroger and Albertsons
Implementing targeted, temporary relief measures for the most vulnerable populations
Encouraging transparency in pricing practices and limiting potentially exploitative dynamic pricing schemes
Reducing supply chain inefficiencies and food waste
These policy solutions would center the American consumer’s needs by deterring anticompetitive practices like price fixing and illegal mergers, curtailing the use of exploitative technology, and ensuring that food is both produced and consumed more efficiently to reduce waste. Reforms like these are needed to create a future where access to affordable, nutritious food is not a luxury but a reality for all Americans.
More like this: